This NIHR-funded trial of cooling the body temperature (therapeutic hypothermia) to treat traumatic head injury was stopped early by the researchers because it appeared that the treatment might be harmful.
People who have severe head injuries from trauma can suffer from injury to the brain, which can be very harmful, even fatal. Survivors of traumatic brain injury can be left with highly variable long-term effects, such as difficulty in communicating, understanding and emotional problems.
This trial was testing therapeutic hypothermia compared to standard care alone to see if it produced benefits six months later. The trial was stopped early because of ethical concerns that outcomes were worse when therapeutic hypothermia was used. Treated patients appeared to have a less favourable functional outcome at six months. They also had higher risk of death. This study indicates that therapeutic hypothermia is probably not effective in people with traumatic brain injury, and may be harmful. But the fact that it was stopped early affects how confident we can be about its conclusions, and a full trial might have had different findings. Further analysis of this and other trials may be required.
Why was this study needed?
Annually, about 200,000 people are admitted to hospital with head injury. Of these, one-fifth have features suggesting skull fracture or have evidence of brain damage (traumatic brain injury). The long-term effects of traumatic brain injury can vary widely in severity, but can include problems with communication, cognition (problem-solving) and emotional changes. An estimated one million people live with the long-term effects of a serious brain injury.
Intracranial pressure is the pressure inside the skull. Swelling or bleeding in or around the brain as a result of head injury can increase pressure, causing damage to the brain or restricting blood supply. Controlled cooling of the body (induced or therapeutic hypothermia) is used to reduce intracranial pressure. However, the evidence for its effectiveness is unclear. The NIHR funded this trial to help doctors decide whether whole body cooling should continue to be used in the NHS for people with raised intracranial pressure after a severe head injury.
What did this study do?
The Eurotherm3235 was conducted across 55 hospitals in 18 countries. The trial randomly allocated 387 people with a traumatic brain injury to receive either standard care alone or with the addition of therapeutic hypothermia. Participants had an intracranial pressure of above 20mm Hg for at least five minutes within the first 10 days of injury and after initial (Stage 1) treatment such as sedation or mechanical ventilation.
Participants’ body temperature was lowered using an intravenous infusion of cooled salt water, then maintained according to the usual protocol at each hospital (for example ice packs or further fluid). Body temperature was maintained between 32 and 35⁰C – the minimum required to keep pressure below 20mm Hg – for at least 48 hours, or for as long as was needed to control intracranial pressure. Both the hypothermia and control groups could receive standard Stage 2 treatments as needed, such as mannitol, a diuretic to increase urine production. If Stage 2 treatment was not successful, then participants received Stage 3 treatment such as sedation or surgery.
What did it find?
- At six months, those who received hypothermia had higher risk of having an unfavourable outcome on the Extended Glasgow Outcome Scale compared with the standard care alone group (odds ratio 1.53, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.02 to 2.30).
- Fewer people in the hypothermia group had a “favourable outcome” – moderate disability to good recovery – 27.5% compared with 36.5% in the standard care group.
- The risk of death by six months was higher in the hypothermia group than in the standard care group (hazard ratio 1.45, 95% CI 1.01 to 2.10).
- Outcomes were not affected by other factors such as age, Glasgow Coma Score, time since the traumatic brain injury or whether the participant was in the UK or elsewhere.
What does current guidance say on this issue?
2014 NICE guidance on the management of head injuries does not provide information about the use of therapeutic hypothermia. Brain Trauma Foundation guidelines on the management of traumatic brain injury concluded that there was no clear evidence that hypothermia reduced mortality. This was based on the pooled results of six moderate quality randomised controlled trials. These trials had various limitations, such as small sample and lack of adjustment for the influence of other factors – which restrict the level of recommendation that could be made for therapeutic hypothermia.
What are the implications?
The study suggests that therapeutic hypothermia in the treatment of raised intracranial pressure from traumatic brain injury doesn’t have benefits and may be associated with poorer functional outcomes and increased mortality risk compared to standard care alone.
The study was pragmatic in allowing local protocols to be followed where possible, increasing its relevance to the NHS. But as with all trials that are stopped early because of an apparent benefit or harm, we should recognise that if the trial had continued, the finding could have disappeared. It seems unlikely that it would have shown benefit however.
Andrews,PJD, Sinclair HL, Rodriguez A, et al; Eurotherm3235 Trial Collaborators. Hypothermia for Intracranial Hypertension after Traumatic Brain Injury. N Engl J of Med. 2015;373:2403-2412.
This project was funded by the National Institute for Health Research Health Technology Appraisal programme (project number 11/01/30).
Brain Injury Group. Brain injury – the facts. Redhill: Brain Injury Group; 2015.
Brain Trauma Foundation. Guidelines for the management of severe traumatic brain injury: 3rd edition. J Neurotrauma. 2007;24(Suppl 1).
Headway. Traumatic brain injury. Nottingham: Headway – the brain injury association; 2015
NICE. Head injury: assessment and early management. CG176. London: National Institute for Health and Care Excellence; 2014.
Sydenham E, Roberts I, Alderson P. Hypothermia for traumatic head injury. Cochrane Database of Syst Rev. 2009;(2):CD001048.
Produced by the University of Southampton and Bazian on behalf of NIHR through the NIHR Dissemination Centre